Journal Policies
- Peer Review Policy
Peer Review Policy
The journal adopts a double-blind peer review system, in which the identities of authors are concealed from reviewers, and the identities of reviewers are concealed from authors, to ensure objectivity and independence and to uphold the integrity of the scholarly evaluation process.
All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo an initial editorial screening to assess their suitability for the journal’s scope, compliance with publication requirements, originality, scholarly quality, and adherence to research and publication ethics. The editorial board reserves the right to reject a manuscript at this stage if it fails to meet the journal’s requirements, falls outside its scope, or does not satisfy the minimum standards of scholarly quality.
Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial screening are sent to qualified reviewers specializing in the relevant field, who possess appropriate academic expertise and have no conflicting interests with respect to the manuscript or its authors that could compromise the independence of their evaluation. Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts according to scholarly criteria, including originality and significance of the topic, methodological rigor, analytical accuracy, the consistency of findings with the supporting evidence, quality of scholarly presentation, accuracy of referencing, and the manuscript’s academic contribution.
Reviewers are required to maintain strict confidentiality, objectivity, and impartiality, and to provide clear, substantiated review reports containing constructive comments to help authors improve their manuscripts. Reviewers may not use the content of unpublished manuscripts for personal or research purposes without the authors’ permission.
Publication decisions are based on peer review reports and the editorial board’s scholarly assessment. The journal may issue one of the following decisions:
- Accept the manuscript for publication without revisions.
- Accept the manuscript subject to minor revisions.
- Request major revisions and resubmission for further evaluation.
- Reject the manuscript.
If reviewers’ reports conflict or are insufficient to support a clear decision, the editorial board may refer the manuscript to an additional reviewer or take any other appropriate measures to complete the evaluation process.
Authors are required to respond to reviewers’ comments, make the requested revisions, and provide a clear scholarly response to each comment, including scientific justifications for any suggestions they choose not to implement.
The editorial board retains final responsibility for publication decisions and is committed to editorial independence. Decisions shall not be influenced by non-scholarly considerations, including institutional affiliations, personal relationships, ethnic, religious, or political considerations, or any other factors unrelated to the scholarly merit of the manuscript.
The journal is committed to conducting the peer review process with integrity, transparency, confidentiality, and fairness, thereby ensuring the quality of its scholarly publications and strengthening the confidence of researchers and the academic community.
- Plagiarism Policy
Plagiarism Policy
The journal is committed to combating plagiarism in all its forms and promoting originality, academic integrity, and respect for intellectual property rights. The journal does not accept for publication any manuscript involving plagiarism or the appropriation of others’ works, ideas, or findings without proper acknowledgment of their sources.
All manuscripts submitted to the journal are subject to originality screening using text-similarity detection tools, where available, in addition to the editorial and scholarly assessment conducted by the editorial board. A high similarity percentage alone does not constitute conclusive evidence of plagiarism. Similarity reports are assessed in light of the nature of the text, the sources of similarity, the appropriateness of quotation and referencing, and whether any content has been reproduced without proper attribution.
Plagiarism includes, but is not limited to, the following practices:
- Copying texts, ideas, or findings from other sources without acknowledging their original authors.
- Quoting sources verbatim without appropriate quotation marks or proper citation.
- Paraphrasing others’ ideas without acknowledging the original sources.
- Translating published works, or parts thereof, and presenting them as original work without citing the original source.
- Reusing substantial portions of an author’s previously published work without appropriate disclosure or citation, thereby constituting duplicate publication or improper recycling of scholarly content.
- Appropriating data, images, tables, figures, or other scholarly materials produced by others without the required permission or acknowledgment.
If plagiarism is suspected before publication, the editorial board shall examine and verify the case. The journal may reject the manuscript, return it to the author for clarification, or take any other appropriate action depending on the nature and severity of the alleged violation.
If plagiarism is discovered after publication, the journal shall investigate the case, contact the authors, review the available evidence, and take appropriate action. Such action may include publishing a correction, retracting the article, or issuing an editorial statement regarding the violation, depending on the severity of the case and the outcome of the investigation.
The journal emphasizes that authors are responsible for the originality of their manuscripts, the accuracy of quotations, the proper attribution of sources, and obtaining the necessary permissions to use materials protected by intellectual property rights.
The journal reserves the right to take appropriate editorial action in all cases of confirmed plagiarism to safeguard scholarly integrity, authors’ rights, and the reliability of the published scholarly record.
- Research Misconduct Policy
Research Misconduct Policy
The journal is committed to maintaining scholarly integrity, promoting ethical research practices, and addressing all allegations or indications of research or publication misconduct seriously and responsibly. The journal adopts a zero-tolerance approach toward practices that may undermine the credibility of scholarly research, mislead the academic community, or violate the rights of research participants, researchers, or institutions.
Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to, the following practices:
- Fabrication: Inventing data or research findings and presenting them as genuine.
- Falsification: Manipulating research data, materials, or procedures, or improperly altering or omitting results in a manner that misrepresents the findings or content of the research.
- Plagiarism: Using others’ works, ideas, texts, or findings without appropriate scholarly attribution.
- Duplicate or overlapping publication: Publishing the same manuscript, or substantial portions thereof, in more than one outlet without appropriate disclosure or the necessary permissions.
- Authorship misconduct: Including individuals who have not made a genuine scholarly contribution to the research, omitting individuals who are entitled to authorship, or falsely claiming scholarly contributions.
- Peer review manipulation: Providing fabricated reviewer identities, improperly influencing the peer review process, or attempting to circumvent scholarly evaluation requirements.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest: Concealing financial, professional, or personal interests that may affect the objectivity of the research or its evaluation.
- Violations of research ethics: Conducting research involving human participants or sensitive data without obtaining the required ethical approvals, where applicable, or without respecting participants’ rights, safety, and privacy.
- Citation manipulation: Including irrelevant citations, coercing unjustified citations, or manipulating reference lists to inflate citation metrics or improperly influence scholarly evaluation.
- Misuse of artificial intelligence tools: Using generative artificial intelligence tools in ways that result in fabricated information, references, or data; compromise academic integrity; or fail to disclose their use when disclosure is required by the journal’s policy.
Procedures for Handling Research Misconduct
Upon receiving an allegation or identifying indications of research misconduct, the editorial board shall conduct an initial assessment, gather available information and evidence, and determine the seriousness of the allegation, while ensuring confidentiality, fairness, and the right of the parties concerned to respond.
Depending on the nature of the case, the journal shall follow the procedures outlined below:
- Initial Assessment: Reviewing the allegation or indications of misconduct and determining whether they are sufficient to warrant an investigation.
- Evidence Gathering: Examining relevant documents, data, correspondence, and materials, and verifying the available evidence.
- Communication with the Parties Concerned: Requesting clarifications or responses from authors or other relevant parties and providing them with an appropriate opportunity to respond.
- Assessment and Investigation: Conducting an editorial or scholarly review of the case and consulting independent experts, where necessary, while avoiding conflicts of interest.
- Decision-Making: Determining the appropriate course of action based on the evidence, the nature of the misconduct, and its impact on the integrity of the research and the scholarly record.
- Documentation: Maintaining an appropriate record of the procedures, correspondence, and decisions relating to the case, while respecting confidentiality and privacy.
Possible Actions
Depending on the nature and stage of the misconduct, the journal may take one or more of the following actions:
- Reject the manuscript before publication.
- Request clarifications or revisions from the authors.
- Suspend the publication process pending the completion of an investigation.
- Publish a correction to the article.
- Issue an editorial statement or alert concerning the article.
- Retract the published article (Retraction) when a substantial violation is confirmed and warrants retraction.
- Notify the relevant academic institution or competent authority, where necessary and appropriate to the nature of the case.
- Take any other editorial action necessary to protect scholarly integrity.
The journal ensures that its procedures for handling research misconduct are proportionate to the nature of the violation, based on reliable evidence, and conducted fairly and impartially, without presuming that misconduct has occurred before the investigation has been completed.
The journal emphasizes that the purpose of this policy is not merely punitive; it is also to protect the credibility of scholarly research, safeguard researchers’ rights, strengthen trust in academic publishing, and preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.
